Why foundations come before 11+ questions
Most 11+ maths questions are not testing one topic. A typical “harder” question asks a child to read a short story, pick out the numbers that matter, choose two or three operations, and work with fractions or decimals along the way. If any one of those building blocks is shaky, the whole question falls over, and it is very hard to see which part caused it.
That is why so many families end up in the same loop: another practice paper, a disappointing score, more practice papers. Papers are good at showing that marks are being lost. They are poor at showing where. A child who gets a fractions word problem wrong may not have a fractions problem at all. They may have a times tables problem that only shows up when they try to simplify.
The research backs up a foundations-first approach. A large study by Siegler and colleagues (2012), using data from the UK and the US, found that children’s knowledge of fractions and division at around age 10 predicted their maths achievement years later in secondary school, even after accounting for general ability, family income and other maths knowledge. The Education Endowment Foundation’s guidance on Key Stage 2 and 3 maths (2017) makes the same point from the classroom side: use assessment to find out what pupils already know, and build fluent recall of facts so that working memory is free for problem solving.
The 11+ bar is above “expected”
In 2024, 73% of pupils in England met the expected standard in KS2 maths at the end of Year 6 (DfE). Grammar schools are selecting from the top of that group, and most 11+ tests are sat in Year 5 or at the very start of Year 6. In practice that means the Year 5 and early Year 6 curriculum needs to be secure, and quick, earlier than school would normally expect.